In the first film, McCall "finds himself caught in the middle of a deadly feud in a frontier mining town", and falling in love with a local girl named Nora, played by . The original screenplay was written by , who, with, convinced of NBC to finance the project.[4] The film was produced by Mirisch's son Drew, who initially hired to direct, but Byrum agreed to withdraw from the position when disharmony arose over the work he was producing. Virgil W. Vogel was then brought in to direct, and helmed the project to completion.
Although the film received "excellent notices and ratings", NBC declined to pick up it up as a series, preferring to order additional 2-hour TV movies continuing the story of the original.
The second film centered on McCall dealing with "a crooked sheriff committing crimes and blaming others". After the second film broadcast, NBC sought to implement a series after all, but by that time, the contract obligating McArthur for a weekly series had expired. The actor, whose star was on the rise, was no longer interested in being "tied up to a weekly series". NBC then ordered two additional TV movies.
The third film centered on a character portrayed by , playing "a desperate man who forces McCall to rescue his kidnapped daughter".
In the fourth film, McCall "learns that he has fathered a son with Nora", and encounters "as a serious-minded lawman, [and] as a cold-blooded killer".
By the end of Badlands Justice, McCall had still not been able to clear his name, leading critics to anticipate further installments resolving this issue; however, no more of the films were made. Universal opted to end the series at this time, because "having a backlog of five of these films, for foreign distribution was about as far extended if they wanted to be".